12.2 C
Spain
Thursday, November 26, 2020

Sweden and China: an old friendship that turned sour

Must read

The Spanish Ministry of Truth

On September 15th, 2020 the Spanish Council of Ministers approved the Draft Bill of Democratic Memory that will punish those who disagree...

In memoriam Lee Teng-hui, first native President of Taiwan

Lee Teng-hui, one of Asia’s most relevant leaders of the 20th century, passed away on July 30th, aged 97.

About the very different drinking culture in Taiwan

In Mandarin, days and months don’t have proper names like in Western languages, but are just numbered. So the 9th of September...

The first James Bond turns 90

Sean Connery, the first actor to play fictional British secret agent James Bond 007, created in 1953 by English writer Ian Fleming...
Flying Dutchman
Flying Dutchman
For detailed biographical information, please check the very first article of this blog. Thanks!

On May 9th, 1950 Sweden became the first Western country to establish diplomatic relations with the communist People’s Republic of China (PRC), proclaimed by Mao Tse-tung (1893-1976) on October 1st, 1949 on the Tiananmen Square in Peking.

Still, Sweden nowadays probably has the worst relationship with China of any member of the European Union (EU), which it joined in January 1995 together with Finland and Austria.

This is the case despite the fact that during these seven decades, Sweden built many economic ties with China. In 2018, bilateral trade was worth about 17 billion US dollars and of all EU states, from 2000 to 2019 Sweden was the seventh-largest beneficiary of Chinese foreign direct investment.

One of the most noticed was the acquisition in 2010 of luxury vehicle manufacturer Volvo Cars by Zhejiang Geely Holding Group, a private Chinese multinational automotive company headquartered in Hangzhou.

Their long friendship deteriorated significantly for political reasons on October 17th, 2015, when Swedish citizen and author Gui Minhai, born 1964 in Ningbo and also known as Michael Gui, disappeared while on holiday in Thailand.

Gui, who since October 2014 had been publishing books in Hong Kong not approved by China’s General Administration of Press and Publication, in 1988 had enrolled in a doctoral program at the University of Gothenburg, located in Sweden’s second largest city.

After the Tiananmen Massacre, the violent crackdown on a reform movement demanding more civil liberties in China on June 4th, 1989 in Peking, he first obtained Swedish residency and later even renounced his Chinese citizenship.

On January 7th, 2016, Gui appeared on Chinese state television, allegedly confessing that he had run over a school girl while driving drunk in December 2003 and returned to his homeland voluntarily to face charges.

Gui was released after spending exactly one year in prison, but denied permission to leave his country of birth. He was rearrested on January 19th, 2018 on a train bound for the Chinese capital while on his way to a medical examination accompanied by two senior Swedish diplomats.

About two weeks later, Gui stated that Sweden had sensationalized his case and tricked him into an unsuccessful attempt to leave China and repatriate him, using a medical appointment at the Swedish embassy as a pretext.

The spat flared up yet again on November 4th, 2019, when the Swedish chapter of PEN International, a worldwide association of writers founded in London in 1921, announced Gui as the 2019 recipient of its Tucholsky Prize.

Outraged by what he considered harmful to his homeland’s interests, Gui Congyou, China’s Ambassador to Sweden since August 2017, dared to say on public Swedish radio: “We treat our friends with fine wine, but for our enemies we’ve got shotguns.”

At the same time, he announced that cultural exchanges and business opportunities would be restricted. Soon afterwards, a Chinese trade mission to Sweden was canceled and some Swedish movies banned from screening in China.

He also warned of the “bad consequences” of this decision, hinting that Swedish Prime Minister Stefan Löfven from the Social Democratic Party wouldn’t be welcome in the Middle Kingdom.

While Culture Minister Amanda Lind on November 15th, 2019 honored an empty chair representing Gui at the ceremony, Löfven on the same day made clear that he would never give in to intimidation.

After reportedly renouncing his Swedish citizenship on February 24th, 2020, a move that cut him off consular access, Gui was jailed for 10 years on charges of “illegally providing intelligence overseas”. Sweden, which had been denied access to the trial, strongly demanded Gui’s release.

Nevertheless, the current government is in fact reluctant to impose tough penalties on China, as Stockholm has to walk a fine line between strong criticism and legitimate concern about a possible retribution from Peking.

However, on April 23rd, 2020 Sweden closed the last of its Confucius Institutes, China-funded programs that teach Chinese language and culture around the world, ending an academic experiment that began in 2005.

On April 29th, Health and Social Affairs Minister Lena Hallengren proclaimed that Sweden would push the EU to support an international investigation into the coronavirus pandemic’s origins, which is bound to look at allegations of a Chinese cover-up.

During the virtual conference of European Union foreign ministers on May 29th, 2020, the day after China approved the national security law for Hong Kong, only one participant asked whether Brussels should at least consider sanctioning the Red Mandarins: Swedish representative Ann Christin Linde.

Simultaneously, as Sweden refused to impose a lockdown and put its faith in “herd immunity,” it has been the prime target of a huge Chinese campaign portraying Western democracies as weak against the threat.

This seems to be the culmination of a strategy: from January 2018 to May 2019, the Chinese Embassy made 57 statements denouncing Swedish media coverage of China.

Not surprisingly, seven of Sweden’s eight biggest newsrooms belonging to national television stations confirmed that had been contacted in recent years with complaints about content.

Somehow, the pressure doesn’t seem to bear fruit: around 70% of Swedes held rather unfavorable views of China, the highest percentage among Europeans and the second-highest worldwide after the Japanese.

On January 21st, 2020 Christian Democrats, the Left Party and Sweden Democrats advocated in the Swedish parliament for Ambassador Gui to be declared persona non grata and therefore prohibited from entering Sweden and meddling in Swedish affairs.

Regarding Anna Lindstedt, who while serving as Sweden’s Ambassador to China from 2016 to early 2019 tried to help Gui, the District Court in Stockholm ruled on July 10th that it couldn’t be proven that she had exceeded her authority and acquitted her of all charges.

They included “arbitrariness during negotiations with a foreign power,” because she failed to notify the Swedish Foreign Ministry before setting up a meeting between Angela Gui, daughter of the imprisoned, and two Chinese businessmen who claimed they could help arrange her father’s release.

Obviously, there were no concrete results and Gui ended up in prison. Though due to the growing mistrust resulting from this case, Swedish authorities increasingly scrutinize or directly advise against Chinese investors.

There are few signs that the bilateral relationship will improve anytime soon. Nowadays, old friends face each other as ideological adversaries. An uncertain future awaits Gui Minhai.

- Advertisement -

More articles

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

- Advertisement -

Latest article

Huang Hua, China’s most important diplomat

Chinese diplomat Wang Rumei, who under his assumed name Huang Hua (“Yellow China”) served as Ambassador and Foreign Minister, died on November...

An epic struggle between good and evil in Spain?

The man that decisively shaped twentieth-century Spain for almost four decades, Generalissimo Francisco Franco, died peacefully on November 20th, 1975 in a...

Spain’s astonishing rise from the ashes after the civil war

After the end of the three-year-long Spanish Civil War on April 1st, 1939, reconstruction under Generalissimo Francisco Franco began quickly and virtually...

November 20th, 1975: Arias Navarro announces Franco’s death

45 years ago on November 20th, 1975, the man that had shaped Spain for almost four decades, Generalissimo Francisco Franco, died in...

Bars or clinics? Different priorities in Spain and Taiwan

Spain is well-known for its amazing number of bars, which have little in common with those in the United States. They are...